Nina's Pizza

Ct W 2 months ago

We ordered the Chicken Riggies pizza for pickup. It was very timely, and HUGE! We honestly didn’t know what to expect as it seems to be a Utica thing.. SO yummy! Definitely recommend.

Adam 2 months ago

Very disappointed. This was some of the worst pizza and wings I’ve had in a long time. The pizza arrived undercooked, with soft, doughy spots in the middle, and it looked like it was thrown together. As you can see from the photos, there were multiple areas with little to no cheese or sauce. The wings were just sitting in a pool of sauce instead of being tossed. If they can’t be bothered to toss the wings in sauce which takes seconds of their time then they definitely can’t be bothered to even keep the place clean and safe for food prep. For the price, the quality was unacceptable and the pizza was edible. I won’t be ordering from here again.

ZabO Hot 3 months ago

Took my order within the last 20 minutes of closing time, had no attitude and greeted me very nicely. I got the riggies and I will be going back , they are delicious and very fresh. I eat mine hot and save some for when it cools down, they tend to get nice and thick :p I will be thinking about this meal for the next 3 days. Thank you for the inredible food and service. :Ps get the garlic bread on the side it’s worth it .

Theresa Marie Edited 3 months ago

6/21/26 delivery, ordered the linguine & white clam sauce. It was the worst tasting white clam sauce & linguine I've ever eaten. Dry as a bone, pasta was all stuck together, with oil at bottom... it was just disgusting. I couldn't even eat it. I Ordered a side salad with balsamic, no dressing received, asked for side of grated cheese, again not received. I called to advise of my displeasure & all I got was an I'm sorry, not much help when I had no dressing for the salad & linguine that had a terrible taste & ended up in garbage.ive never seen macaroni salad made with rigatoni & no mayo, quite odd indeed. See attached pic. The eggplant parmesean was good, as was the carrot cake. $90 & except for eggplant dinner & desserts the rest was just awful. Doubt I'll order again since nothing was made right when I called & advised of my issues.

Shelly 6 months ago

We were in Utica last nigh and I had a craving for chicken riggies, so we decided on a whim to try Nina’s Pizza—and they did not disappoint! I ordered the chicken riggies and they were amazing. The portion size was epic and the flavor was exactly what I was hoping for. My boyfriend got the steak riggies and loved his as well. The kids all enjoyed their meals too, which always makes a big difference when eating out as a family. The staff was super friendly and really welcoming, which made the whole experience even better. Great food, generous portions, and lovely staff. We would definitely go there again!